Mary Peltola defeats Dan Sullivan in Alaska Senate race

Mary Peltola defeats Dan Sullivan in Alaska Senate race

Democrat Mary Peltola unseated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, giving Democrats a 56-seat majority in the U.S. Senate after a two-week ballot count.

Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, according to a projection from NBC News, securing her party’s 56th Senate seat following the midterm elections. BBC News reported that election workers took two full weeks to tally ballots across the state’s remote expanse before calling the contest from the Nov. 3 vote.

A broader Senate majority

Peltola’s victory gives Democrats a 56-44 majority in the Senate, Fox News reported. The result marks the ninth Republican-held seat flipped by Democrats in the midterm cycle. All but one of those nine flipped seats came in states won by President Donald Trump in 2024, when Trump took Alaska by about 13 percentage points.

The Alaska win means Democrats will hold full control of Congress during the final two years of Trump’s presidency, having also recaptured the House of Representatives. The 56-member caucus will include independent Sens. Angus King of Maine and Bernie Sanders of Vermont, who caucus with Democrats. It stands as the largest Senate majority either party has held in 16 years, with the caucus adding representatives from states including Texas, South Carolina, Kansas, and Mississippi, where Democrat Scott Colom won earlier this month.

The controversy over two Sullivans

The race drew national attention because of a dispute over Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher and political newcomer who shared nearly the same name as the two-term incumbent, Dan S. Sullivan. Republicans alleged that Democrats recruited the second Sullivan to confuse voters and siphon support from the senator. The New York Times reported that Peltola campaign aides, attorneys, and national Democratic operatives took part in an effort dubbed the “ballot composition project” to recruit candidates against Sullivan.

Both the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee denied any involvement, and Dan J. Sullivan said running was entirely his own decision. Alaska election officials initially tried to remove him, but the Alaska Supreme Court ruled he could stay on the ballot. Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy directed state officials to investigate whether the recruitment effort broke state law.

The legal fight reached federal court when the Justice Department sued to block Alaska Senate certification if the incumbent Republican lost, an action Trump said he ordered. Trump also called for Peltola to be prosecuted. A federal judge threw out the administration’s request to separate ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan just days before Election Day.

In the end, the dispute did not affect the outcome. Under Alaska’s ranked-choice voting rules, voters rank four candidates, and lower finishers are eliminated if no candidate receives an outright majority. Because Peltola captured more than 50% on the first round of voting, officials never triggered ranked-choice tabulation. A BBC Verify analysis determined that Peltola still would have won even if every ballot cast for Dan J. Sullivan had gone to the incumbent.

How the campaign played out

Sullivan, a Marine Corps veteran and former Alaska attorney general, sought a third term by pointing to his work on national defense and state energy development. He aligned himself with Trump, who traveled to Alaska in mid-October to campaign for him. Sullivan attacked Peltola as ineffective in Washington, saying that if she ran an ad listing her legislative accomplishments, “that would be the shortest ad in American history.”

Peltola focused her campaign on rising consumer costs, the Iran war, and high fuel prices, linking Sullivan directly to Trump’s second-term policies. Alaska has not voted for a Democratic presidential candidate since 1964, but Trump never climbed above 55% in the state across three elections. Peltola also dominated the financial race, collecting $37 million in direct contributions compared to Sullivan’s $14 million through mid-October.

Tuesday night, Peltola celebrated her projected win in a post on X, and in her victory statement she said the “status quo in DC is not working for Alaska” as she pledged to focus on lowering costs for families.